Tuft and Needle Vs Casper

Tuft and Needle Vs Casper

by Si

We currently participant in a few affiliate programs and may receive referral fee for items purchased through our site. This does not cost our readers anything, to learn more please visit our Disclosure page.


Tuft and Needle Vs Casper

Torn between 2 mattress brand, read our Tuft and Needle Vs Casper review.

Sleep experts recommend that you should replace your mattress with a new one at least once every few years to get the best quality sleep for your body. It’s normal for mattresses to wear over time, and after a few years a mattress will have lost the firmness and bounce that made it a great bed.

When it’s time to replace it, the first thing you’ll notice is the thousands of choices out there. A lot of people don’t put nearly this much thought into their first mattress, only to be completely befuddled when they have to buy a new one – it seems almost too complicated when you’re hit with thousands of different mattress brands.

Tuft and Needle and Casper are two of the most popular brands on the market. If you want to improve how you sleep, either of these can make for a great choice.

Here’s more about what defines the Tuft and Needle and Casper brands, and what you should know about each of these when making your choice for a new mattress.

Comparison – Tuft and Needle Vs Casper

Quick Pros and Cons

Tuft and Needle and Caspar are one of the two top mattress brands on the market today; both of them are known for their exceptional quality, extended warranties on their products that show just how much they believe in what they sell and their individual promises to provide you with a great night’s sleep.

But how do they stack up against one another?

Here’s more about the pros, cons and defining features of each:

Tuft and Needle Vs Casper Firmness

Tuft and Needle Mattress


  • All Tuft and Needle products come with an extensive warranty that guarantees your product against damage for at least 10 years from the date of your purchase.
  • The Tuft and Needle mattress is made from what they called Adaptive foam, special memory foam that’s been designed to conform to the shape of your body without feeling too soft.
  • Memory foam is known for being very prone to absorbing heat, but the Tuft Needle mattress has been crafted to stay cool throughout the night for the best sleeping experience possible.


  • The Tuft and Needle mattress is lower to the ground than it should be, which is uncomfortable for some.
  • For heavier sleepers or people who sleep more on their stomach, this bed just isn’t as comfortable as it could be and the Casper will be a better bet.
  • The Tuft and Needle weighs in at far over 70 pounds, and if you already have back problems, you’ll need help to move and shift it.

Casper Mattress


  • The Casper mattress offers four layers of foam for more support when you need it most.
  • For some extra added support, the Casper has what’s called zoned support that offers the right kind of support for your neck – and a different kind of support for your hips.
  • The Casper mattress has been designed to stay cool throughout most of the night, which is one of its best features.


  • You can put the Tuft and Needle mattress down on the floor if you don’t have anything else, but this isn’t true for the Casper – and you’ll need to get a base or box to put this bed on.
  • While the Casper stays cool for most of the night, it can retain heat too much if you’re a sleeper with a naturally high body temperature.
  • The Casper mattress is far more prone to what’s called off-gassing, the strong chemical smell that comes with buying new memory foam – let it air for a few hours to days before using it.

Tuft and Needle Vs Casper – Mattress Construction

How the mattress is constructed is one of the most important factors when you’re making your choice. You want strong construction that will make the bed resistant to bouncing and movement, and you want a mattress that’s built for comfort at the same time with just the right amount of layers to support your back, neck and hips.

Here’s more about the construction of each.

Tuft and Needle Construction & Layers

Tuft and Needle mattresses are made with only 2 layers, which the manufacturer claims is all you’ll ever need for the most comfortable sleeping experience you’ll ever have. These layers are made of special Adaptive memory foam and graphite-infused materials to ensure that it stays comfortable and cool. Statistics claim that 95 out of every 100 people are happy with their beds, and it’s pretty clear that they aren’t lying. The Adaptive memory foam is made to offer different kinds of support for your neck and your hips at once – perfect if you have back or sleeping problems that need to be fixed; for this, the Tuft & Mattress can give you a proper night’s worth of sleep: The best you’ve had in years.

Casper Construction & Layers

The Casper mattress has a strong construction, and they’re confident enough to give clients a 100 night return policy – if you aren’t happy with the mattress, just send it back. Instead of offering you just two layers like the Tuft and Needle mattress, the Casper offers you four – and this can make the Casper last a little bit longer as well as offer you added comfort.

Tuft and Needle Vs Casper – Mattress Performance

The most important factors when you choose your new mattress should be firmness, comfort and support; if a mattress doesn’t match these three, it’s likely that you’re not going to buy it – and not going to be happy with it if you do.

Here’s how the Tuft and Needle and the Casper mattresses perform when they are compared in the most important factors.


The Tuft and Needle mattress consists of only two layers, but it’s firmer than you might think – and the manufacturer is so confident of their product that they give it to you with a 10 year warranty that guarantees your product against any damage for that period. This is better and more than most.

Having said this, for the best firmness right out of the box, there’s the Casper mattress – which is a little firmer than the Tuft and Needle when you get it.


Both the Tuft and Needle and the Casper mattress rank pretty high up when it comes to comfort, but when you have to choose between the two it will depend on what you’re looking for.

If you have special needs for your back, neck and hips then you should choose the Tuft and Needle for the best comfort because of the Adaptive memory foam; if you’re looking for simple support and a great bed, the Casper should be your choice.


Different people need varying levels of support in their mattress; ask yourself what your needs are before you make your choice.

For support after a back injury that warrants a flatter, firmer sleeping surface, you should choose the Casper mattress. But if you’re looking for special distributed support, then the better bet is going to be the Tuft and Needle.

Off gassing & Temperature

Off-gassing is something that you’ll see with many products that are shipped, especially things like mattresses, pillows and clothes – and it’s something that you’ll almost always experience with mattresses, particularly those that are made of memory foam.

If you’ve never heard the term before, it refers to the gases released by new memory foam – and the smell isn’t pleasant; it’s highly chemical. Even though it’s not toxic or dangerous in any way, it just smells weird and you might have to let the mattress air.

When it comes to off-gassing, the Tuft and Needle mattress has been reported as being worse – and you might have to leave it out for a few days (at least two) to get the smell to air out. All it takes is some proper ventilation.

Tuft and Needle Vs Casper – Sleeping Positions

People sleep in different ways, and no two people are the same; if you sleep alone, you might have to record yourself sleeping to find out just what kind of sleeper you are and which mattress is best for your needs.

Here’s how the Tuft and Needle and Casper mattresses match up against one another when it comes to sleeping positions, and which will fit you best depending on which kind of sleeper you are.

The Tuft and Needle Mattress

The Tuft and Needle mattress is an excellent mattress option for most types of sleepers: Side and back sleepers will love this one, and especially side-sleepers will love this one because of its Adaptive memory foam that supports your shoulders and your hips in an individual way, which is what a lot of sleepers (especially those with back injuries) really need.

Which sleeping position is suited to which mattress?

The Casper Mattress

Consider all of the factors when you want to buy your mattress; a lot of people sleep only on their side, while many people are combination sleepers. You should also consider the other factors of the mattress overall (like the comfort and firmness) when choosing your mattress.

The most important question to ask yourself: What’s your idea of a proper night’s sleep?

The Casper mattress also happens to be ideal for most types of sleepers, and it’s got four layers of specially designed foam that will help you sleep comfortably – some back sleepers have reported that the Casper isn’t as comfortable as it should be for them, though this is down to individual preference, and no two back sleepers will ever feel the same.

Comparison – Tuft and Needle Vs Casper

Tuft and Needle Vs Casper – Who would benefit

Choosing the right mattress can change the way you sleep, change the way you feel you wake up and change the way you live – in fact, choosing the right mattress can change your entire life.

Here’s who can get the most benefit out of the Tuft and Needle and Casper mattresses – and one more thing that you should think about when getting your new mattress.

Tuft and Needle Mattress

The Adaptive memory foam the Tuft and Needle mattress is equipped with is a great choice if you happen to be a sleeper with special needs from a back injury that needs some extra taking care of; even if you don’t have a back injury and just want a supportive mattress, you can still get a lot of strong, firm support from the Tuft and Needle – and it stays cool throughout the whole night.

Casper Mattress

The Casper mattress can also be suited to some people with hip, spinal or shoulder injuries, although with severe injuries it can sometimes feel like it doesn’t offer enough support – ask your doctor if you aren’t sure which of the two mattresses can give you enough support. If you just need a great night worth of sleep, then the Casper is also a great choice – though some back sleepers have reported discomfort.

Tuft and Needle Vs Casper Review - Wrap Up

If you aren’t sleeping right, developing back and neck pain or not feeling as great as you should during the day, there’s a good chance that it could be because of your mattress: In any case, it’s a good idea to replace your mattress once every few years, and the Tuft and Needle mattress and Casper mattress are two of the best ones you can choose.

Consider all the important factors when choosing your bed – including what you consider to be your  idea for an ideal night’s sleep; this is important because everyone has different sleeping needs and you need to find what’s right for YOU.

Whether you choose Tuft and Needle or Caspar, you’re making a great, comfortable choice.

More Snooze Related Articles